When pain or injury strikes, diagnostic imaging plays a crucial role in uncovering what’s happening beneath the surface. Two of the most common imaging tools — the X-ray and the MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) — serve distinct purposes.
At Cawley Physical Therapy & Rehab, we believe that informed patients make better recovery decisions. Understanding what an X-ray shows vs. what an MRI reveals can help you feel confident about your diagnosis and treatment plan.
This guide breaks down the differences between X-rays and MRIs, when each is used, what they detect, and how physical therapy contributes to your recovery journey.
Understanding Diagnostic Imaging
Diagnostic imaging refers to noninvasive tests that allow healthcare professionals to see inside the body and identify injuries, abnormalities, or conditions affecting bones, joints, muscles, and organs.
The two most common imaging tools — X-rays and MRIs — differ in technology, detail, and purpose.
What Is an X-Ray?
An X-ray (radiograph) is a quick, painless imaging test that uses low-dose radiation to create pictures of the inside of your body — primarily bones. The X-rays pass through soft tissue but are absorbed by dense materials like bone, creating a clear contrast on the image.
What X-Rays Show Best:
- Bone fractures or breaks
- Joint dislocations
- Arthritis and bone degeneration
- Bone infections (osteomyelitis)
- Bone alignment issues or deformities
Common Uses in Physical Therapy:
At Cawley PT, many patients are referred for X-rays before beginning physical therapy to rule out:
- Acute fractures after a fall or sports injury
- Structural abnormalities before manual therapy
- Advanced arthritis or bone spurs
What Is an MRI?
An MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) uses powerful magnets and radio waves — not radiation — to produce detailed 3D images of soft tissues, muscles, tendons, ligaments, nerves, and cartilage.
Unlike an X-ray, which primarily visualizes bone, MRI technology can reveal soft tissue injuries and inflammation that aren’t visible on standard radiographs.
What MRIs Show Best:
- Muscle or tendon tears (e.g., rotator cuff, hamstring)
- Ligament sprains or ruptures (e.g., ACL, MCL)
- Disc herniations or bulges in the spine
- Soft tissue swelling or inflammation
- Cartilage damage (meniscus, labrum)
- Nerve compression (sciatica, cervical radiculopathy)
Common Uses in Physical Therapy:
Your physician may order an MRI before or during physical therapy if:
- Pain persists despite conservative care
- Symptoms suggest nerve involvement or soft tissue damage
- The injury is complex or unresponsive to initial treatment
X-Ray vs. MRI: Key Differences
| Feature | X-Ray | MRI |
| Type of Imaging | Uses ionizing radiation | Uses magnets and radio waves |
| Best For | Bones and joints | Soft tissue, ligaments, tendons, discs, nerves |
| Detail Level | Basic structural images | High-definition cross-sectional images |
| Radiation Exposure | Yes (low dose) | None |
| Duration | 5–10 minutes | 30–60 minutes |
| Cost | Generally lower | More expensive |
| Comfort Level | Quick and simple | Can feel confined (MRI tube) |
Both imaging tools have unique strengths. X-rays excel at identifying fractures and bone changes, while MRIs reveal muscle, tendon, and nerve injuries that an X-ray cannot detect.
When Do You Need an X-Ray vs. an MRI?
When an X-Ray Is Typically Ordered:
- You’ve experienced trauma (e.g., fall, car accident, sports injury)
- You have sudden, sharp bone pain or visible deformity
- There’s suspicion of arthritis, bone spurs, or scoliosis
- To confirm healing progress after a fracture
When an MRI Is Typically Ordered:
- You have chronic pain not explained by an X-ray
- There’s muscle weakness, tingling, or numbness suggesting nerve involvement
- You’ve been diagnosed with a soft tissue tear
- Your pain worsens despite treatment
- You’re recovering from surgery and your physician needs detailed tissue imaging
What an X-Ray Doesn’t Show That an MRI Does
An X-ray cannot visualize:
- Muscles or tendons
- Ligaments
- Cartilage
- Discs or nerves
- Internal swelling or inflammation
If you’ve had an X-ray that appeared “normal” but your pain continues, your provider may order an MRI for a deeper look at soft tissue damage or nerve compression.
The Role of Physical Therapy After Imaging
Whether your diagnostic test shows a bone injury, muscle strain, or joint dysfunction, physical therapy plays a crucial role in recovery.
At Cawley Physical Therapy & Rehab, our clinicians interpret imaging results in collaboration with your healthcare team to design a personalized treatment plan that promotes healing, strength, and mobility.
Our Evidence-Based Approach Includes:
- Manual therapy: Restores joint mobility and reduces stiffness
- Therapeutic exercise: Rebuilds muscle strength and stability
- Neuromuscular re-education: Improves posture and movement patterns
- Pain management techniques: Including dry needling, ultrasound, and soft-tissue mobilization
By addressing not just the injury but its underlying cause, we help patients return to activity safely and confidently.
Get Clarity and Start Healing
If you’re unsure whether your pain is bone, muscle, or nerve-related, schedule your free consultation with Cawley Physical Therapy & Rehab today. Our experts can guide you through the right next steps — including whether an X-ray or MRI may be appropriate.
Contact Us Here
Common Misconceptions About X-Rays and MRIs
“I need an MRI for every injury.”
Not necessarily. Many conditions — like minor sprains, muscle tightness, or joint stiffness — can be accurately assessed by a physical therapist without advanced imaging.
“An MRI is always more accurate.”
While MRIs offer more detail, they aren’t always better. Sometimes, they can show “abnormalities” unrelated to your symptoms. The key is clinical correlation — matching imaging results with your pain pattern and exam findings.
“Physical therapy only starts after imaging.”
In many cases, physical therapy can begin even before imaging results are available — especially for common musculoskeletal issues. Your therapist will monitor symptoms and coordinate care with your physician if further imaging is needed.
When to Seek Medical or Imaging Evaluation
You should see a healthcare provider if you experience:
- Severe or worsening pain after injury
- Numbness, tingling, or weakness in limbs
- Difficulty walking, bending, or lifting
- Unexplained swelling or deformity
- Pain that doesn’t improve after a week of rest
Early assessment ensures appropriate imaging, accurate diagnosis, and faster recovery.
Why Choose Cawley Physical Therapy & Rehab?
At Cawley Physical Therapy, we combine diagnostic insight with clinical expertise to provide:
- One-on-one personalized care at every visit
- Licensed, highly trained therapists specializing in orthopedic rehabilitation
- State-of-the-art manual and therapeutic techniques
- Multiple convenient locations in Wilkes-Barre, Scranton, Trucksville, Pittston, Kingston, Nanticoke, Mountain Top, Factoryville, and Carbondale
No referral needed — start your recovery today!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. Which is better for back pain, an X-ray or MRI?
X-rays show spinal alignment and bone changes, while MRIs reveal disc issues, nerve compression, or soft tissue injury. Your doctor or physical therapist can determine which is needed based on your symptoms.
2. Are X-rays safe?
Yes. The radiation exposure from a single X-ray is very low and considered safe for most patients.
3. How long does an MRI take?
A typical MRI scan lasts 30–60 minutes depending on the area being imaged.
4. Can physical therapy help even if imaging shows nothing?
Absolutely. Many types of pain are caused by muscle imbalance or movement dysfunction — both treatable with physical therapy even when imaging appears “normal.”
5. Do I need a referral for physical therapy after imaging?
No. In Pennsylvania, you can see a physical therapist directly without a physician referral.